Thursday, December 16, 2010

A Mement In Time...

The suspense of Memento continues to grow as the movie moves forward (or backward).  The plot of the movie is quite complex, but the real beauty of the movie is the perspective from which the plot is told.  The camera is of course our portal into Leonard's world.  We see what Christopher Nolan intends for us to see and in the order he intends for us to see it .  It is really questionable thought as to whether this adds or takes away from the film.  The black and white shots that cut the "action" of the movie into pieces are a nice touch.  I also like how each scene "starts" with the "end" of the scene.  This keeps you interested because you are asking what events led Leonard to his current predicament.  For instance, when he is sitting on the bathroom toilet with a bottle of wine in his hands, the viewer is curious and thinks, "  Is he a drinker? He says he doesn't feel drunk.  But why else would he have a bottle of wine? And why in the bathroom of all places?  Who's house is this anyway?"  And that of course brings us to the other interesting observation that Lenny doesn't really care where he is when he wakes up.  He follows his instincts.  He wants to shower. He showers.  Doesn't seem to give it a second thought.  He doesn't even bother to look outside of the bathroom.  Both Lenny and the audience are kept in the dark most of the time.  Lenny doesn't seem to always be doing so much exploring of his own so we  have no choice but to go with it.  So in that respect I like the chronology of the film.
      But I am still not sure if I like the entire film being shown out of order.  It makes the viewer feel confused and ignorant like the main character and this may have been Nolan's goal.  But this confusion can become a bit much.  It really is very hard to remember what happened when.  Even in class yesterday we were having trouble reconstructing the order of events.  But perhaps that is exactly what Nolan was trying to accomplish.
     Apart from camera work, the plot of the movie continues to develop and give us some explanation.  There are still many questions left on answered though.  Why is there a pick up truck with bullets in it?  Was there really a second guy in the bathroom the night  that Lenny's wife was murdered?  Who is trying to use Lenny and who is trying to help him? Who is Lenny always talking to on the phone? etc etc....            Also Mr Bennett I dont think you gave the class enough credit for pinning Natalie as someone who is using Lenny.  We all thought she was rather suspicious and I personally stated that she was behind this whole mess. Now I understand I have not yet seen the ending and dont know many key things, but thus far it certainly appears that Natalie is really at the root of all of Lenny's problems.  But i guess that's the point.  You can't trust your senses.  And the suspense keeps building....

2 comments:

  1. I see I am accused yet again. I don't think you're being quite fair. I didn't ask whether Natalie was untrustworthy, I asked whether she was responsible for Leonard killing Teddy. I didn't congratulate the class on seeing through Natalie because I thought any reasonably intelligent person would see that without much help. And see it you did.

    What I was trying to elicit, successfully, thanks to Raymond, is the possibility that Leaonard is the one who is responsible.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well in the end you are right it is Lenny who leads to his own downfall. But thats why i stated that i hadn't seen the end of the movie yet i was just using what i already knew (or thought i knew). The plot twist of Lenny being the real "evil" character is quite interesting and although I think it definitely adds to the ending of the movie I still wish he wasn't. He has a mostly likable character : he's funny, witty, smart, amiable and resourceful. I still find it much easier to cheer against Natalie Im not sure why. Maybe its just that after disliking a character for so long its hard to switch sides. I just saw Inception and apart from several others flaws I think the Christopher Nolan made a mistake by making DiCaprio a character who is impossible to like because he is constantly misleading people and making mistakes. You want to cheer for him but you just cant he is too on the fence. Sometimes its even better to have an evil character thats so evil you can cheer for him. For instance the Joker is certainly the most entertaining character in the Dark Night and while you know and want for Batman to prevail in the end most people still enjoy the fascinating evil character of the Joker the most. I dont like conflicting characters. In the Simple Plan Hank is one of those characters. He is a god guy that does some really terrible things for money. His wife is pretty easy to dislike but you feel bad for him. I prefer it when the director makes the characters more clean cut like death from the Seventh Seal. Hes just evil death, thats it...

    ReplyDelete